The Chartered Insurance Institute (CII) Public Trust Index showed the speed of claims rose from the seventh highest priority for consumers in July 2021 to the third highest priority in July 2022.
Control over the claims process has moved from ninth priority to the sixth highest priority over the same period.
The cost of living crisis is likely behind the change, according to the CII.
Matthew Connell, director of policy and public affairs for the CII, said: “We launched the Public Trust Index to help measure trust in the insurance profession, and our findings today reveal the desire for faster claims processes during times of stress and uncertainty.
“The last time consumers felt this strongly was during lockdown in May 2020. Consumers do rate the value of the premiums they are paying as important, but quality of complaints handling, and the clarity on policy wording is rated higher.
“With the FCA’s measures on renewal premiums in place for less than a year, the Public Trust Index shows this is an area of greatest dissatisfaction. It’s likely consumers feel that they should be rewarded for their loyalty, not penalised, and put at a financial disadvantage.”
