The Association of Mortgage Intermediaries’ (AMI’s) Protection Viewpoint report also found that the proportion of consumers who had never started their protection journey increased from 65% in 2025 to 72% this year.
The report further highlighted that advised customers were more likely to have explored and hold protection. Of those who hold any protection, 58% sought advice compared to 23% who had never had finance advice. Half of advised customers had received a protection quote, against 10% of non-advised customers.
However, given the fact 43% of advised customers had never received a protection quote, the AMI said the timing of protection conversations ought to be reconsidered.
Only 25% of consumers would return to same adviser
Most advisers – 41% – said they revisited protection conversations around the fixed rate period, while 39% re-engaged with clients when there was a known change in circumstances.
Grasping the next buy to let opportunities
Sponsored by Aldermore
However, only a quarter of consumers expected to return to their existing adviser for their next mortgage review. For 24% of consumers, they would deal directly with their bank or building society, and 18% would source their next mortgage themselves.
Craig Hall, director of strategic partnerships at LSL Financial Services, said the industry had traditionally built its protection model around mortgage reviews, but risked losing contact with clients who did not return when their deal ended.
He said the most successful advisers carried out annual financial health checks rather than waiting for clients to refinance every 2-5 years. This regular contact also helped advisers retain clients amid competition from other advisers, lenders, comparison sites and artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots.
Hall added: “The more contact an adviser has with their clients, the stronger the bond and trust, which ultimately makes it easier to overcome the objections they come up against.”
Tackling consumer reluctance
When seeking mortgage advice, consumers were primarily focused on keeping their monthly payments affordable, cited by 47% of respondents. However, 19% said their main concern was how they would cope if their circumstances changed.
When consumers declined protection, the most common response was that they would look into it later, according to 49% of advisers. A further 45% said consumers believed they did not need cover.
John Scrivens, sales director at Stonebridge, said: “This research really strikes at the heart of the problem for advisers. It is that customers don’t always say what they mean or tell you what they really want.”
When asked how they engaged consumers on protection needs, more than three-quarters (77%) of advisers said they brought potential risks to life, while 58% said they explained the importance of financial resilience.
Scrivens added: “When customers show a reluctance to engage in conversations about protection, that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re not interested. This is why the psychology of the advice process is so important. Advisers have to ask the right question at the right time in the right way if they are to help the customer recognise their needs in a way that creates momentum.”
Stephanie Charman, the AMI’s chief executive, said the Protection Viewpoint report aimed to make protection a more natural part of consumers’ wider financial planning.
She added: “A key part of this is recognising we may be asking consumers to consider protection before we’ve helped them understand its relevance to their lives.”