The mutual saw a similar 27.3% decline in new mortgage customers, totalling 6,668 during the year.
Sue Hayes, chief executive of Nottingham Building Society, said 2025 had been a year of “deliberate consolidation” for the business, following two years of strong double-digit growth.
She added: “We made a conscious decision to moderate lending while continuing to prioritise substantial investments in our systems, processes, and capabilities to strengthen long‑term resilience and enhance our operating foundations.
“This ongoing programme is designed to ensure the society is well-prepared for its next phase of purposeful innovation and sustainable growth – and well-positioned to deliver for members in the years ahead.”
Last year, Nottingham Building Society launched its broker portal, backed by MQube’s Origo technology.
Grasping the next buy to let opportunities
Sponsored by Aldermore
Hayes said the broker portal was “already transforming our lending operations by reducing time to offer, improving decisioning capability, and significantly enhancing broker experience”.
She added: “This marks a key milestone in our evolution as a specialist residential lender and positions us strongly as we scale further into specialist segments in 2026. Alongside this, we continued to grow our specialist lending proposition through our partnership with Gen H, which has now supported over 5,000 new homeowners with around £1bn of funding from the society.”
The mutual said the resilience of its borrowers remained strong, with 0.75% of accounts in arrears of 30 days or more, up from 0.55% the year before.
Its total mortgage assets were valued at £4.3bn, slightly higher than the previous year’s £4.2bn.
The mutual reported a 20.1% increase in its profit before tax to £16.7m, while its underlying profit before tax declined by £1.9m to £20.9m.
Aiming to grow responsibly
Hayes said: “Looking ahead to 2026, we expect continued economic uncertainty and the likelihood of further bank rate reductions, requiring careful management of our net interest margin. With strong foundations now in place, our focus turns to scaling our specialist lending proposition, further enhancing member experience across every channel, embedding our technology investments and continuing to strengthen our operational resilience, data and cloud capabilities.
“Our recent inclusion in the Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority’s inaugural Scale‑up Unit cohort further reflects our ambition to grow responsibly and at pace, while maintaining the highest regulatory standards. We enter 2026 as a modern mutual with momentum, clarity of purpose and the capability to deliver sustainable, long‑term growth for our members.”
Nottingham Building Society also announced that Anthony Murphy would be stepping down as CFO and leave the mutual in May to spend time with his family. The mutual has begun the process to find a successor.
Hayes said: “I would like to thank Anthony for his significant contribution. During his time, we have achieved strong profitable growth, significantly enhanced the rigour and quality of our financial management and regulatory reporting and delivered £1bn of forward-flow funding with Gen H.
“We also delivered our inaugural residential mortgage-backed securitisation (RMBS) issuance, a landmark transaction for the society that demonstrated the growing sophistication of our treasury capabilities. I thank Anthony for his contribution and wish him well for the future.”