user.first_name
Menu

Sponsored content

Affordability isn’t a number. So why do we still treat it like one?

Aldermore
Affordability isn’t a number. So why do we still treat it like one?
Posted:
November 19, 2026
Updated:
November 19, 2026

Brokers know better than most that a mortgage case rarely begins and ends with a number.

A calculator might tell you how much a customer can borrow, criteria might tell you whether they fit and an affordability model might produce a neat yes or no. But none of those things necessarily tell you whether the lender has really understood the customer, and that distinction is becoming increasingly important.

Customers’ working lives are changing, Income can come from contracting, self-employment, multiple sources or running a business. Credit histories can contain bumps that say more about a difficult period than they do about someone’s circumstances today. Yet too often, complex customers are still expected to fit into simple boxes which for brokers, that creates a familiar frustration: a case can make sense when you look at the whole picture but struggle the moment it meets a rigid model.

The FCA’s Mortgage Rule Review suggests the industry may be starting to recognise that tension with its proposals considering whether lenders should have greater flexibility to assess customers using their full and current circumstances, including those with variable or irregular incomes and some borrowers with previous credit difficulties.

That doesn’t mean lowering the bar for responsible lending, it means getting better at deciding who can responsibly clear it.

 

The customer hasn’t necessarily become riskier, their circumstances have become harder to put in a box.

Take two customers earning £50,000. One is employed on a fixed salary the other is a contractor whose income varies throughout the year. A company director might draw £50,000 personally while the underlying business tells a much bigger story. The headline number might be identical but the cases aren’t. That’s why affordability needs to go beyond what does this customer earn? The better questions are: How do they earn it? How sustainable is that income? And what does the wider picture tell us?

That isn’t about taking more risk, it’s about understanding the risk you’re actually taking.

The same is true of credit history

A missed payment, default or CCJ of course matters, but the presence of adverse credit and the story behind it aren’t the same thing. What happened? When did it happen? Was it isolated or part of a pattern? Has the situation been resolved? And, crucially, what has the customer done since?

Those are questions brokers ask every day because context can completely change how a case looks. The FCA’s proposals raise an important question for lenders too: should a historic event automatically define today’s customer, or should lenders have enough flexibility to understand what sits behind it?

That isn’t about ignoring adverse credit, it’s simply about interpreting it properly.

Brokers are already doing the hard part

This is where I think brokers have a head start. Good brokers don’t see applications as a collection of data points they see the customer behind them. They know why a contractor’s day rate needs context and they understand why a company director’s salary and dividends might not tell the whole story. They know when an old credit issue needs explaining rather than simply flagging.

And they know something else that is becoming increasingly important: the lender offering the biggest affordability number isn’t necessarily the right lender for the customer.

Sometimes the difference is the lender willing and able to understand the case which changes the broker conversation.

It becomes less about who will lend the most? and more about who is best equipped to understand this customer?

Flexibility shouldn't mean lowering standards

There is an important line here with more individual assessment cannot become an excuse for weaker affordability decisions. Customers still need to be able to afford and sustain their mortgage, and lenders still need to lend responsibly. But rigorous doesn’t have to mean rigid and the opportunity is to move from a model-led assessment to a more informed assessment where appropriate.

The objective isn’t to make it easier to say yes, it’s to make sure we’re not saying no for the wrong reason.

What does that mean for brokers?

It means understanding the lender behind the rate and criteria is going to matter even more. When a straightforward case fits a straightforward model, technology can do much of the heavy lifting but it’s the cases that don’t fit neatly where broker expertise really comes into its own.

Knowing which lenders will consider complexity and what information an underwriter will need could change the way a case is viewed. And knowing when picking up the phone may achieve more than running the customer through another calculator.

Because as lending becomes more individual, lender knowledge becomes more valuable, not less with Brokers not simply matching customers with products they’re matching customers with lenders capable of understanding their circumstances.

And that brings us back to affordability which isn’t a number on a screen, it’s a judgement about a customer’s income, commitments, circumstances and ability to sustain borrowing over time.

The FCA’s Mortgage Rule Review points towards a framework that could give lenders more room to recognise that and for brokers, the opportunity is bigger than finding customers a larger loan.

It’s finding the lender that sees the customer, not just the calculation.