There’s a glaring sticking point with the appeal of new-build buy-to-let. The price.
New homes usually carry a premium over similarly sized older properties in the same area. At a time when mortgage rates, tax and rising operating costs are putting pressure on landlord margins, a higher purchase price is likely to reduce yield.
Frankly, it might not even be possible for some landlords. The numbers won’t always stack up on new build in terms of rental affordability calculations, so this is clearly not a strategy for every landlord or in every part of the country.
But it shouldn’t be dismissed either, because the local figures can tell a different story. Zoopla research published in 2024 found 30 local authority areas where a three-bedroom new build was cheaper than a comparable resale home, with the best savings in the South East and South West of England.
Winchester offered the best value for a new-build home, with the average three-bed costing £118,500 (22%) less than a resale counterpart. In Coventry, a three-bed new build cost £36,200 (15%) less than older homes, and in East Lindsey, the difference was £26,000.
New build can make financial sense for some landlords in some places, but the purchase price and yield are not the only things to consider.
Landlords need to think about achievable rent, tenant demand, mortgage costs, service charges, likely maintenance and how long they plan to keep the property. They should also weigh the cost and disruption of improving an older home against any premium attached to buying new.
This is where brokers can add value. You know your local market and can help landlord clients understand the bigger picture.
New-build buy-to-let obviously won’t suit every client. But for landlords looking for a more energy-efficient property, fewer immediate maintenance demands and greater certainty over costs, it could well make sense.