You are here: Home - Better Business - Business Skills -

On the MMS: The price of everything and the value of nothing – Stephen Smith

by: Stephen Smith is a non-executive director and mortgage market commentator
  • 02/07/2018
  • 0
On the MMS: The price of everything and the value of nothing – Stephen Smith
Oscar Wilde often has the best lines. In his play “Lady Windermere’s Fan” he has Lord Darlington say that a cynic is “a man who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing”.


This came to mind when reading the FCA’s Mortgage Market Study Interim Report with its apparently “cynical” focus on price as the main determinant of a good mortgage customer outcome and its apparent dismissal of the value of advice.

The analysis contained in section five of the report focuses on the degree to which customers could have got a cheaper priced deal than that recommended to them by an adviser. There is very little discussion at all about the myriad of other factors which a good adviser will take into account when making a recommendation of not just product, but lender too. I believe that there is more to value than just price. It’s not all just about the money.


Price at any cost


If the rest of our lives were lived out on this “cynical” basis, then we’d all be driving Dacia cars, flying RyanAir and buying our clothes at Sports Direct. And on an adventure holiday, we’d be first in the queue for a firm advertising “cheap bungee jumping”.

Let’s just look at the other factors that an intermediary may take into account when deciding which lender to recommend to their client.

They may consider how fast and smoothly a case may go to offer – normally a critical factor in house purchase cases. Does the broker know the lender’s systems to be able to submit the case efficiently?

Do they know its soft underwriting factors, and have a good relationship with the underwriters to discuss grey areas about the case which the sourcing system will not display?

What will be the lender’s attitude to further borrowing if it is needed? What is its reputation for treatment of customers with payment difficulties? What are the criteria around property acceptability – acknowledging that a lending decision is only partly about the acceptability of the creditworthiness of the customer ?

And, given the experience of the last few years, is it a lender who is going to stay around, or go out of business and sell on their customers to a faceless hedge fund?

These sort of factors are never going to be programmed into a price comparison site or even the most extensive sourcing system. Even the most advanced of the robo-advice models are still in the “machine learning” phase of AI development and have therefore to supplement the work of the algorithm with real human advisers.


Quality will out


So, having established that the advice process can actually add value into the lender and product selection process, what other benefits does advice provide ?

Well, properly advised customers are a better bet for lenders. They will, if the job has been done well, understand the commitment they are taking on. They will have discussed and considered the length of any fixed rate they are taking out. They will have discussed the protections they may need to maintain their lifestyle and protect their home.

Lenders should want, and I believe, do want, advised customers. In the USA this has been taken a step further, where the funder Fannie Mae will give discounted rates to borrowers who have taken an online training course to prepare to borrow, and have successfully proved themselves to be “qualified borrowers”.

I hope that many of you will take the opportunity before the end of July to explain to the regulator how there is more to value than price and the genuine value of the advice service you provide.


There are 0 Comment(s)

You may also be interested in

Business Skills

In this section, we offer short ‘how to’ guides on harder to crack areas of business. From social media, to regulation or niche product areas, we cover it all.


Our journalists interview key industry entrepreneurs, strategists and commentators for day-to-day market insight and a strategic view of where the industry is heading. We offer lessons for success and explore the opportunities for your business

Success in Practice

Here, we share case studies fleshing out best practice to help you decide what could work for your business. Take a look at how others approached complex tasks like launching a new mortgage lender, advising on a new product area or deciding to specialise in another. Learn from others mistakes and triumphs.


Each week, we ask top mortgage and property commentators with a unique perspective to examine a key news headline, market move or regulatory or political issue.


Vote in our weekly poll here. It’s your chance to tell us what you think and be heard on the top news stories of the week. Review our archive to find out what your industry really thinks and all our coverage of the results.

Top Comments

Be part of the conversation on Mortgage Solutions. We want to hear from you. We have a tool called Disqus to tell us which stories get the most comments each week. Every Friday, the team picks the most thoughtful or opinionated contributions from our readers to enjoy again. Don’t forget to share your favourite stories from the site on social media to keep the conversation going.
  • Richard Beardshaw, head of sales, mortgage intermediaries at HSBC UK for Intermediaries welcoming the brokers to to…
  • We are in Allianz Park today for the first in the series of HSBC UK for Intermediaries Breakfast Seminars
  • At this year’s Later Life Lending Event Richard Rowntree from Bank of Ireland for Intermediaries will be presenting…
Read previous post:
Handshake across a desk
Purplebricks expands into Canada with £29.3m deal

Purplebricks is expanding into Canada with a £29.3m takeover deal.